EMDR Practitioners: Why Incorporate the Parts Approach into Your Protocols?
Logbook: “A Meeting Without Power Struggles”
To explain the value ofthe “parts” approach, I’ll imagine an indoor conference room. One voice wants to move forward. Another checks the exits. A third asks if we’ve even understood what might happen. If the therapist supports only the one who wants to move quickly, the others won’t necessarily leave the room—they might cut off the power. Enthusiasm for the protocol is no substitutefor agreement on the terms of the work.
This scene is a metaphor, not a claim that separate characters live inside the brain. The “parts” framework can help some people distinguish between conflicting tendencies without reducing one of them to a flaw. “Part of me wants to change, while another part fears the consequences” can spark more curiosity than “I sabotage everything.” Provided, of course, that this way of speaking truly resonates with them .
I’m particularly interested in what hesitation protects. The fear of losing control, of disappointing a loved one, or of being overwhelmed can contain crucial clinical information. Recognizing this does not mean letting it take complete control. It allows us to negotiate a pace and a framework within which work remains possible. A productive meeting does not require everyone to applaud; it requires that no participant be silenced just to speed up the agenda.
A person wants to move forward but fears what the work might bring to the surface. They ask to explore a memory, but then become hesitant as soon as it becomes clearer. For the practitioner, the temptation is to look for what is blocking the process. Another question might be more fruitful: “What is this hesitation trying to protect?”
The “shares” approach provides a framework for exploring this ambivalence without immediately turning it into an obstacle.
The Parts: A Model for Understanding the Inner Experience
IFS, which stands for “Internal Family Systems,” proposes understanding one’s inner life as a set of parts that serve, among other things, protective functions. This framework can help a person describe conflicting feelings: wanting to be close to others while fearing dependence, seeking change while dreading the loss of one’s sense of security.
"Parts" are not anatomical structures. Using this terminology also does not allow for the diagnosis of a dissociative disorder. It is a therapeutic model, which must remain a concept that is understandable and acceptable to the individual.
Some patients identify with this. Others prefer to talk about needs, reactions, or tendencies. Their language should guide our work.
Understand a form of protection before trying to eliminate it
A costly strategy can serve a sensible purpose. Control may be an attempt to prevent the unpredictable.Avoidance may limit distress. This does not mean that every reaction is beneficial, but rather that an intervention would benefit from considering what it would replace.
In EMDR, this reading can support the preparation for and discussion of informed consent. If the person fears being overwhelmed, explaining the protocol in greater detail is not always the answer. It is important to understand this fear, clarify the options for stopping the session, and reassess the pace.
Integration is useful when it addresses an identifiable clinical challenge. It loses its value if it adds complex terminology to work that is already clear.
Let’s start by having a conversation.
Integration does not mean demonstrating superiority
Research onIFS is expanding, particularly through the PARTS program. It does not allow us to conclude thatthe combination of IFS and EMDR is systematically superior to EMDR alone. Studying an intervention derived from IFS does not equate to validating all possible combinations. PARTS study registry.
The practitioner must therefore be able to explain why they are suggesting this interpretation, what they expect from it, and how they will assess its value. A EMDR training does not, on its own, constitute comprehensive training in IFS, and vice versa.
The model must remain focused on serving people
Reflective Practice According to Donald Schön
In *The Reflective Practitioner*, published in 1983, Donald Schön examines the knowledge that professionals draw upon in their work and their ability to reflect on what they do. I find this framework particularly valuable when multiple approaches intersect.
The right question isn't just "Would this tool be useful here?" It's about what this tool allows us to understand, verify, and adjust. Donald Schön, 1983.
The Relationship Between IFS and EMDR
In integrating IFS and EMDR, I therefore wish to maintain a certain discipline:
- Articulating the Challenge
- Explain the choice
- Observe the response
- Be willing to change the assumption
Fancy vocabulary can give the impression of depth without actually improving understanding. If the person feels lost in a theatrical production they never asked to be cast in, we need to go back to their own words.
Consistency in Care and Its Framework
My notebook would have this sentence in it:
"Integration is measured by the
consistency of care
, not by the number of logos on the toolbox."
Training, clinical expertise, and supervision make it possible to question this coherence. Research on a method does not automatically validate all of its applications. Recognizing this limitation does not detract from therapeutic creativity; rather, it provides a framework within which it can be examined rather than simply admired.
A language that is suggested, never imposed
The “parts” approach may make sense to a practitioner who is familiar with it. To the person being counseled, it may seem intuitive, strange, or too abstract.
It is therefore necessary to present this vocabulary as a possibility. The patient must be able to say that he or she does not identify with it without this refusal being interpreted as further resistance. A method loses its purpose when it makes it impossible to give any response that does not confirm its model.
A simple formulation can be based on words that are already there:
“You describe both a desire to move forward and a fear of what that might
change.”
We can explore this tension without immediately identifying protectors or internal categories. If the language of “shares” subsequently provides clarity, it can be introduced and discussed. The model should support the experience, not provide a script for it to follow.
This caution also applies to the images and dialogues presented. A representation that emerges during a session is subjective material. It does not constitute proof of a historical event or provide access to a hidden truth.
The practitioner bears responsibility for the way in which they ask questions and respond to what emerges. Openness to the experience must remain consistent with caution regarding interpretations and memory.
Would you like to find out if EMDR en visio is right for you? Let's have a chat together.
Linking the preparation to a clinical decision
Understanding a protective reaction does not mean that we should seek the hypothetical consent of each party before taking any action. Such a rule could make the preparation process endless. Our reasoning must remain grounded in what the person is able to express and experience: Is the proposal understood? Is refusal possible? Is the person aware of how to signal a difficulty? And is there still enough contact to allow for participation?
The work may lead to narrowing a goal that is too broad. Instead of immediately focusing on the entire history of a relationship, it may be better to clarify the current difficulty or to strengthen certain sources of support. This decision does not automatically follow from the vocabulary used. It is based onthe assessment, the context, the practitioner’s skills, and the dialogue with the patient.The “parts” approach is then one tool for understanding among others.
It is helpful to keep a record of the reasoning: what challenge prompted the use of this model, what response was observed, and what factors justify the next steps? If the integration does not provide any clarity or actually increases confusion, it should be revised. The value of a tool is not measured by the richness of the discussion during the session, but by what it actually helps us understand and adjust inthe counseling process.
Distinguishing Between Ambivalence and Dissociative Difficulty
Clinical Distinction and Limitations of the Model
Feeling split is not sufficient grounds for a diagnosis of clinical dissociation. Conversely, significant difficulties with the continuity of experience should not be dismissed simply as a matter of parts that are at odds with one another.
These situations require an evaluation and, depending on the case, a specialist’s opinion. The model does not replace clinical judgment and does not automatically provide the expertise needed to manage all clinical presentations.
Accurate Observation in Supervision
In supervision, it is particularly helpful to describe observations before naming them:
- What change was noticed?
- Was the person able to answer?
- How was the end of the session experienced?
- What is known between matches?
This clarification prevents the group from discussing only a theoretical category and losing touch with what actually happened.
Professional Competence and Transparency
Training in an integrative approach also requires an awareness of one’s limitations. Knowing how to present the IFS, understanding its concepts, and using it on an ad hoc basis are not three equivalent levels of competence.
Practitioners must be able to clearly articulate their training and what they actually offer. This transparency protects patients and improves the quality of collaboration with other professionals. It allows practitioners to approach their work with curiosity without letting their enthusiasm for a particular approach turn into certainty about its appropriateness.
A question to bring up in supervision
Rather than asking, “What technique should I add?”, I suggest starting with this question: “What elements underpin my hypothesis about the function of this reaction?”
This question allows us to examine the risk of suggestion, potential dissociation, and the patient’s actual role in decision-making. Within the EMDR PEPS ecosystem, the integration of different approaches must remain focused on achieving this clinical precision.
If you’re looking to incorporatethe parts approach into your practice, supervision can help you clarify your indications and boundaries before adding new tools.
Would you like to find out if EMDR en visio is right for you? Let's have a chat together.



